House Of Sparky: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: The Pros and Cons of an 18-game NFL Schedule

Charting The Depths: Quarterback

A recurring segment where we tackle your 2008 #16 Arizona State Sun Devils football team, position by position, and see what our strengths and weaknesses should be for the upcoming campaign.

We start where every football team starts: Quarterback.

1. Rudy Carpenter 46d6r518_medium

6'3, 220 lbs senior. 2007 stats - 246/398 62%comp rate, 3202 yards, 25TD/10INT good for a 145.09 rating.  Rudy was also sacked a record-breaking 54(!) times.

2008 outlook - A couple things to note about the incumbent starter. First, at the beginning of the 2007 season Rudy was listed by most media outlets, and ASU, at 6'2, 202 lbs. Apparently he has grown an inch and put on 18 pounds (of what we can only hope is muscle) in the offseason.  This is good, because who knows what kind of pounding he will take with our young offensive line. 

Rudy's confidence, judging from comments he has made in the offseason, appears to be at an all time high.  It is his second year under coach Dennis Erickson, however, it is the first year under offensive coordinator/quarterbacks coach Rich Olson.  Olson has followed Erickson around throughout his career, with pit stops in Miami, Seattle, and San Fransisco.  He is considered to be a good coach, and it will be interesting to see what they do with the spread offense in the pac-10 this year.

I am not sure if we will be serious title contenders though, if Rudy is the same Rudy as he has been in the past. With a not-so-great deep ball and the tendency to be one of the most streaky quarterbacks in division I, it will be key to see if Rudy has taken some steps forward as a senior.

2. Danny Sullivan Danny_20sullivan_medium
6'5, 240, Jr. 2007 stats - 7 games, 19/29, 66% comp, 212 yards, 2TD/1INT, 142.79 rating. 

2008 outlook- Most of those stats came in Sullivan's 7/14, 114 yard, 1TD performance in the 4th quarter of the Pacific Life Holiday Bowl last winter against the University of Texas. That performance likely firmly entrenched himself as Rudy's backup, but it would be a strong signal that the season is over if Sullivan is forced to step onto the field.  A timid player, he has at times flashed a cannon arm, but with a lack of confidence and experience, lets hope Sun Devil nation does not have to see him playing unless we are blowing some scrub team out like NAU or Stanford..

The Others:

Jack Elway, Samson Szakacsy, and Chasen Stangel. Elway (Yes, he is the son of THAT Elway.) is a true freshmen, and Stangel and Szakacsy are redshirt freshmen.  They are all in the mix for the 3rd spot on the depth chart and it will be interesting to see how it plays out. Stangel was the top recruit out of the three, but is the smallest at 6'0, 210 pounds.  Rivals.com ranked him as the #16 pro style quarterback in the nation in his recruiting class. Szakacsy is known for his accuracy and mobility and is considered a goof fit for Erickson's offense.  Elway has the name, and the arm, reportedly able to throw it 60 yards or more already. How this one plays out will simply come down to how the three are able to grasp the offense.

Depth: A-

With a solid starter, a solid backup, and three projectable freshmen waiting in the wings, Quarterback is not a position of need for the Sun Devils, and fans should be pleased with what the team is putting on the field for 2008.  The grade is lowered due to Rudy being a known commodity, and one that is just not quite an elite college player. But a very good one.

0 recs  |  Comment 5 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Incredible size and pedigree

Your qb’s have amazing size! And one can only hope Jack Elway like the Manning brothers has benefited from having a NFL qb for a father.. That being said Rudy Carpenter is the least athletic looking 6 foot 3 230 lbs qb I’ve ever seen.. Quite honestly he makes Jared Lorenzen look like Mr. Universe.

by bdoyle86 on Aug 4, 2008 9:26 AM MST reply actions  

And That's After

Carp put on Twenty-something pounds in the off season.

by Baked Biedrins on Aug 4, 2008 12:08 PM MST reply actions  

Sam is the guy...

...that I have high hopes for. Elway’s Cherry Creek team was throttled in the Colorado playoffs and a large reason for it was Elway’s 7 ints against Grandview.

I love the smell of commerce in the morning

by Red Reign on Aug 5, 2008 10:28 AM MST reply actions  

finally an ASU blog on SB nation

but I find this lingering negativity about Rudy to be disturbing though. It’s almost as if you wish he would have transferred rather than Keller. Which in retrospect is quite insane.

Rudy has never had the support of a “complete team” , EG that loss to Texas last year-could it be that they had like way better players than us? I think so. His 10 wins last year—mostly smoke and mirrors and Rudys guts and creativity. So-So longball?? Oh bullshit.

Rudy has more guts than brains and maybe he should have benched himself in 2006 for those 3 bad games when he had two bad hands.    That's the only thing I hold against him

Rudy is 3-0 V UA-and if he goes 4-0 his name should immediately go on the “ring of honor” for that accomplishment alone-the fact is his resume reflects what he is-an outstanding college QB.

by baal on Aug 8, 2008 7:01 AM MST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to House Of Sparky, a site dedicated to ASU athletics. Please join our community of diehard Sun Devil supporters!
Start posting about the Sun Devils »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Thomas2_small
Pac-10 SB Nation blog NCAA 11 showdown.
P1_marshawn_small
House Of Sparky? More like House Of AWESOME!

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

E-Mail Us

Facebook_medium

Feel free to e-mail us at HouseofSparky@gmail.com with any questions, comments, or contributions.

We have a Twitter page. Follow us at http://www.twitter.com/houseofsparky now!

SBNation.com Recent Stories

John Calipari wears a broad smile after being introduced as the new Kentucky basketball coach during a news conference in Lexington, Ky., Wednesday, April 1, 2009. Before the press conference Kentucky's athletics board approved an eight-year, $31.65 million contract that will make Calipari the highest paid coach in the nation. (AP Photo/Ed Reinke) +1 updates

Anthony Davis Jr. Commits To Play For The Kentucky Wildcats

Louisville coach Rick Pitino speaks to an official during the second half of Louisville's 78-76 win over Connecticut in an NCAA college basketball game in Storrs, Conn., on Sunday, Feb. 28, 2010. (AP Photo/Thomas Cain)

Verdict In: Karen Sypher Found Guilty On All Six Counts, Including Extortion, In Rick Pitino Trial

damonevans +5 updates

Greg McGarity To Replace Disgraced Damon Evans As Georgia AD

More from SBNation.com >


Managers

Sparky__1__small Cory Williams

46d6r518_small ASUBoyd

Contributors

N10030361_41353390_734_small mlev811